Unlike those other members of her family, Janet Jackson's albums
are still worth waiting for. The best parts of All for You, her
first disc since 1997's The Velvet Rope, continue to display the
first-class pop-R&B talent who broke through decisively in the
mid-'80s with "What Have You Done for Me Lately" and "Nasty."
Jackson's longtime cohorts Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis are of course
on board, and the production-writing trio demonstrates its mastery
of everything from dirty funk ("You Ain't Right") to peppy,
radio-perfect ("Come on Get Up" and 2000's No. 1 "Doesn't
Really Matter") and hypnotically undulating sounds ("When
We Oooo"). While much of All for You is irresistible, its handful
of failures are poorly conceived and executed. Most glaring among
these is "Son of a Gun (I Betcha Think This Song Is About You),"
an unlistenable sequel to Rope's "Got 'Til It's Gone"
that substitutes one self-regarding singer-songwriter diva (Carly
Simon) for another (Joni Mitchell), thereby wrecking Simon's one
golden moment, "You're So Vain." "Son of a Gun"
and "Truth" apparently target estranged husband Rene Elizondo,
but Jackson is hardly as convincing a revenge artist as she is a
sex kitten. In fact, the likes of "Love Scene (Ooh Baby)"
and "Would You Mind" out-spice even the carnally obsessed
Velvet Rope and Janet.
Teaming with her most accomplished collaborators, producer-songwriters
Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis, Janet Jackson delivers what is easily
her finest record since Rhythm Nation--and arguably her best ever.
Highlights include jams like "You" and "Got 'Til
It's Gone," which recontextualizes samples from War and Joni
Mitchell, respectively; the funky memorial to a dear departed, "Together
Again"; and a slinky cover of Rod Stewart's "Tonight's
the Night." Best of all, though, is "What About."
An accusatory throwdown for a lover who beats and cheats even as
he professes his love, it swings angrily between tender quiet and
raging bitter funk.
"Free at last / Out here on my own," Janet Jackson sings
on the title track of her 1986 blockbuster, Control, an album about
personal liberation, romantic longing, and, of all things, sexual
responsibility. After two albums of middling dance-pop that were
comfortably in the Jackson family mold, Janet dropped in on the
burgeoning Minneapolis funk factory of producers Jimmy Jam and Terry
Lewis and came up with five top 10 hits, including the opening triad
of "Control," "Nasty," and "What Have You
Done for Me Lately," as well as the yearning "When I Think
of You" and "Let's Wait Awhile," that rare song (considering
some of Janet's hits to come) about not having sex. In its own way,
Control is the most convincing declaration of artistic independence
since Stevie Wonder's "Music of My Mind."
Picking up where the breakthrough funk-pop of Control left off,
Janet Jackson and her production team of Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis
laced Rhythm Nation with high-minded references to societal ills--seldom
the favored province of dance music, but a daring attempt nonetheless.
Songs like "State of the World" and "The Knowledge"
follow in the tradition of "free your mind and your ass will
follow." Still, aside from the title track, it was the pure
pop fare and dance music that stormed the charts: "Escapade,"
"Love Will Never Do (Without You)," "Alright,"
and "Come Back to Me" concentrate on the politics of personal
relationships, not public policy, while "Black Cat" burns
the place down with a fierce burst of hard rock. Rhythm Nation 1814
doesn't necessarily hang together thematically, but it's so chock
full of hits, you scarcely notice.
Why is Janet Jackson's Janet the best Michael Jackson album since
Thriller and the best Madonna album since..., well, since ever?
Perhaps it's because Michael's kid sister is the only one of these
three aerobic video stars with enough smarts to realize that sex,
hooks, and beats are all that matter in this field of lightweight
dance pop. Or perhaps it's because the sexuality Janet radiates
through her sweet melodies and hip-tugging grooves is so much more
credible than Michael's arrested prepubescence or Madonna's nothing-personal-just-business
comeons. After her embarrassing posture as a sociocultural analyst
on 1989's Rhythm Nation 1814, Janet has returned to her strength--using
her odd mix of girlishness and maturity to make dance numbers about
personal relationships ring exceptionally true. Even so, the 75-minute,
27-track Janet doesn't really work as an album; there's too much
filler and the between-song transitions quickly grow tiresome. The
album is full of killer singles, though, starting with such proven
cuts as the extremely slinky "That's the Way Love Goes"
and rock-guitar-driven "If," and featuring such future
hits as the Prince-like "This Time," the Motown-like "Because
of Love," the breathy ballad "Where Are You Now"
and the inspired Stax cover, "What'll I Do.
This decade-spanning compilation charts the singer-dancer-actress's
transformation from rebellious teenager to sexy diva, along the
way check-listing major hits like "Nasty," "Miss
You Much," "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" and
"Rhythm Nation." Two new tracks bookend the set, but even
the older material--most of it helmed by writer-producers Jimmy
Jam and Terry Lewis--holds up remarkably well.